Sunday, August 22, 2010

I am responding to question 7

Countries with more power do not have a particular obligation to less powerful countries. Why should it be their duty to help them? Obviously, the countries with more power have it for a reason. They were albe to establish themselves and jump into the political pool. These countries with less power are always unstable. they have interstate issues that disable them from having power. I know then you get the well lets go help them. They don't want help half the time. Look at Iraq, theywere a less powerful country who had what we wanted. Our abligation to help them had to do with the fact that they had oil. We're there now trying to force their ethnic groups to get along. How did that end up our problem? It never was. Less powerful countries need to learn to deal on their own. Once we start to support them it's never going to end. obviously, tp the Untied States seems to be the only country to think we have this obligation. Do you see other countries rushing in to help other people. The same goes for rich countries helping poorer countries. The United States is supposed to be a rich country yet we're what 13+ trillion dollars in debt. I don't see where we're getting the money to help less fortunate countries. I do feel bad for them, but there is no way that we should be obligated to help them when we can't help oursleves.

2 comments:

  1. I think that you bring up good point about the powerful countries interfering when the other country does not want help. You used a very good example that I think most people would easily understand.

    However, what about when a poor country is in need of aid and they ask for it, should a country that is able to help be obligated to, or should they ignore it and go on about their on lives? I'm not sure in all circumstances, but thats just something I thought of when reading your post.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, if it's like a natural disaster then yes we do have a right to help. It would be the ethical thing to do. I just think that we feel more of these things are an obligation because we have ot look good. I htink alot of it still had to do with power though. I think we also have to think about the fact of how did we get to be powerful. We worked hard and didn't really rely on other countries. I mean we broke away from the British and built up. I believe oorer countries can do it to. With us going in we are establishing this form of power there. We could only be leading ourselves into another revolution. Which means another war on foreign territory which results in need for more money that we don't have. I mean look at all the attacks in Iraq on American troops because they don't like what we're doing. the idea of obligation to assit a poorer nation is just our excuse to gain more power over individuals. It's going to come back and bite us in the butts.

    ReplyDelete